Aaron Judge did as Aaron Judge usually does and homered into the right field seats in the fourth inning at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday night. But thats only where the interesting part in The Bronx began. Padres right fielder Fernando Tatis Jr. leaped at the wall and couldnt make the catch but a fan in the first row of the Carlos Ruiz Jersey stands did, snagging Judges 12th long ball of the season. The ball has been returned Jomboy Media (@JomboyMedia) The green-jersey-wearing fan who caught the ball in his glove started celebrating with a group of supporters, jumping up and down in pure jubilation. Only there was one problem. Explore More A fan in a green shirt catches Aaron Judges home run ball in the fourth inning on May 6, 2025. JASON SZENES/NY POST The fan celebrates after catching Aaron Judges home run. JASON SZENES/NY POST Amid the exaltation in the seats, the ball trickled out of the fans glove and rolled along the top of the wall in front of a fan in a gray jersey, who slyly snagged the ball and pocketed it, seemingly without the other group knowing. A fan next to the person in the gray jersey apparently ended up with the ball at some point, and they ended up returning it to the group who had originally caught the ball, leading to a selfie with the souvenir. All of this was captured by the YES Network cameras and eventually narrated by play-by-play man Michael Kay. Eventually the ball was returned back. Jomboy Media/X Aaron Judge watches his solo home run on Tuesday night. Robert Sabo for NY Post Watch the guy in the gray jersey, Im going to take this and put it right in my pocket nobody saw it,' Kay imagined the fans thought proce s. I just love the casual way nobodyll see this. Only the YES cameraman saw it, analyst Paul ONeill pointed out. What looked like a potential fourth straight lo s quickly became a huge night for the Yankees after they rallied for a 10-run seventh inning after relievers Adrian Morejon and Wandy Peralta imploded. The two teams will finish their series on Wednesday night with aces Max Fried and Dylan Cease set to do battle. Matt Strahm Jersey